Financial advisors for high earners in Indiana
Updated
Which financial advisor should I talk to as a high earner in Indiana?
For high earners in Indiana, talk to a fee-only planner who focuses on tax and cash flow as much as investing. High income with modest assets is a poor fit for minimums and percentage fees, so ask how you'd be charged. Records to start with include Seth Shepherd of Pillar Wealth, Alyssa Hause of Hendershott Wealth Management and John Sidery of Uptick Partners.
Where to start
Chosen from what each record shows: credentials that fit this work and fees on file, one advisor per firm.
- Seth Shepherd Pillar Wealth, Franklin Holds the CFP. Fees on file: hourly, one-time planning fee.
- Alyssa Hause Hendershott Wealth Management, Fishers Holds the CFP. Fees on file: ongoing planning fee.
- John Sidery Uptick Partners, Westfield Holds the CFP. Fees on file: percentage of assets.
- Logan Valentine Valentine Wealth Management, Seymour Holds the CFP. Fees on file: percentage of assets, ongoing planning fee.
- James Miller Blend Wealth, Indianapolis Holds the CFP. Fees on file: ongoing planning fee.
- Wesley Kotys Kotys Wealth Professionals, Valparaiso Holds the CFP. Fees on file: percentage of assets, hourly.
How many fee-only financial advisors in Indiana work with high earners?
The Wellspent public graph lists 33 fee-only advisors for high earners in Indiana, at 12 firms. We counted every advisor record that lists this work, as of October 2026.
Where are fee-only advisors for high earners in Indiana located?
Of the 33 fee-only advisors for high earners in Indiana, 8 are in Fishers, followed by 8 in Carmel and 4 in Indianapolis.
Plus 7 in other cities.
How do fee-only advisors for high earners in Indiana charge?
The most common fee among fee-only advisors for high earners in Indiana is a percentage of assets, used by 58% of the 33 with fees on file. Many use more than one: 48% charge an ongoing planning fee and 27% charge fixed fees.
How much do fee-only financial advisors charge in Indiana?
Fee-only financial advisors in Indiana charge a median of $3,500 a year for ongoing planning. We found this across the published prices of 14 Indiana firms.
What credentials should a financial advisor for high earners have?
For high earners, look for the CFP. In Indiana, 48% of the 33 advisors listed hold the CFP.
- CFP48% in Indiana
- The CFP covers insurance and saving decisions together.
How do Indiana advisors for high earners compare with the rest of the US?
58% of fee-only advisors for high earners in Indiana charge a percentage of assets, compared with 84% of the 1,551 listed across the US. That's the largest difference in the Wellspent public graph between the two groups.
Dark bars are Indiana. Light bars are all US advisors for high earners.
Does Indiana tax income on top of federal tax?
Yes. Indiana has a state income tax, so a financial plan for a Indiana resident should project it alongside federal tax.
Is there a local income tax in Indiana?
Yes. In Indiana, every county adds a local income tax.
What should I ask a financial advisor as a high earner in Indiana?
- Do you have a minimum, and do you take clients on income rather than assets?
- Which accounts should I use once I've maxed my 401(k)?
- How would you reduce my tax this year and next?
- How much should I be saving, in dollars?
- How do you account for local income tax where I live and work?
How current is this list of fee-only advisors for high earners in Indiana?
Wellspent last checked these records against SEC records in October 2026 and firm websites in October 2026. Each advisor's page shows the date for that record.
All 33 advisors
| Advisor | Firm | City | Credentials | Fees |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Seth Shepherd "Financial Advisor" didn't make sense to us, so we built Pillar Wealth to reflect people in 2026 instead of 1990. Don't be stuck in the past with an old, outdated formula that incentivizes laziness. Avoid any AUM model. Avoid someone labeled "Financial Advisor" who sells products like insurance. | Pillar Wealth | Franklin | CFP | Hourly, One-time planning fee |
| Logan Valentine | Valentine Wealth Management | Seymour | CFP | Percentage of assets, Ongoing planning fee |
| Tim Woodward | Blend Wealth | Indianapolis | CFP, MBA | Ongoing planning fee |
| Jennifer Rupp | Hendershott Wealth Management | Fishers | CFP, MBA | Ongoing planning fee |
| Alexis Woodward | Blend Wealth | Indianapolis | CFP | Ongoing planning fee |
| Benjamin Kuhlman | Valentine Wealth Management | Seymour | CFP | Percentage of assets, Ongoing planning fee |
| James Miller | Blend Wealth | Indianapolis | CFP | Ongoing planning fee |
| Wesley Kotys | Kotys Wealth Professionals | Valparaiso | CFP | Percentage of assets, Hourly |
| Joel Koon | Four Quadrant Wealth Advisors | Carmel | CFP | Percentage of assets, Fixed fees |
| John Sidery | Uptick Partners | Westfield | CFP | Percentage of assets |
| Matthew Bates | Four Quadrant Wealth Advisors | Carmel | CFP | Percentage of assets, Fixed fees |
| Thomas Kopelman We help high net income/ high worth business owners manage their entire financial life. | AllStreet Wealth | Carmel | Not listed | Flat fee or retainer, One-time planning fee |
| Alyssa Hause | Hendershott Wealth Management | Fishers | CFP | Ongoing planning fee |
| Ashley Bradford | Hendershott Wealth Management | Fishers | CFP | Ongoing planning fee |
| Hilary Hendershott | Hendershott Wealth Management | Fishers | CFP | Ongoing planning fee |
| Hollina Wadsworth | Hendershott Wealth Management | Fishers | CFP | Ongoing planning fee |
| Kristy Larm | Hendershott Wealth Management | Fishers | CFP | Ongoing planning fee |
| Scott Dunlap | Human Capital Wealth Management | Fishers | Not listed | Percentage of assets, Ongoing planning fee |
| Treyton DeVore | Allstreet Wealth | Westfield | Not listed | Percentage of assets, Ongoing planning fee |
| Drew Vesling | Kotys Wealth Professionals | Valparaiso | Not listed | Percentage of assets, Hourly |
| Dustin Hunter | SunRift Capital Partners | Plainfield | Not listed | Percentage of assets, Hourly |
| Kevin Good | Pillar Wealth | Franklin | Not listed | Flat fee or retainer, Ongoing planning fee |
| Ryan Kotys | Kotys Wealth Professionals | Valparaiso | Not listed | Percentage of assets, Hourly |
| Wyatt McCullough | Pillar Wealth | Franklin | Not listed | Flat fee or retainer, Ongoing planning fee |
| Brogan Baxter | Four Quadrant Wealth Advisors | Carmel | Not listed | Percentage of assets, Fixed fees |
| Bryan Fawcett | Four Quadrant Wealth Advisors | Carmel | Not listed | Percentage of assets, Fixed fees |
| Gregory Forsythe | Forsythe Wealth Management | Crown Point | CFA | Percentage of assets, Hourly |
| Jason Smith | Four Quadrant Wealth Advisors | Indianapolis | Not listed | Percentage of assets, Fixed fees |
| Kal Owen | Four Quadrant Wealth Advisors | Carmel | Not listed | Percentage of assets, Fixed fees |
| Stacy Phillips | Four Quadrant Wealth Advisors | Carmel | Not listed | Percentage of assets, Fixed fees |
| William Chrisman | Four Quadrant Wealth Advisors | Carmel | Not listed | Percentage of assets, Fixed fees |
| Robert Hendershott | Hendershott Wealth Management | Fishers | Not listed | Ongoing planning fee |
| Ryan Forsythe | Forsythe Wealth Management | Crown Point | Not listed | Percentage of assets, Hourly |
Want a shorter list for high earners?
Tell us what you need and we'll narrow Indiana's 33 advisors to the few who fit.
Get matched in 2 minutes